Toyota Highlander Years to Avoid: What Not to Buy

The Toyota Highlander is a favorite among SUV enthusiasts because of its spacious interior and smooth handling. However, not all Highlanders are created equal. While some models have earned their reputation as dependable family haulers, others have frustrated owners with their recurring problems.

If you’re considering purchasing a used Toyota Highlander, you must know which Toyota Highlander years to avoid. Don’t worry because this guide will help you avoid costly mistakes.

Problematic Years for the Toyota Highlander

Over the years, Toyota Highlander models have been known to have different issues. So, which years stood out the most for recurring complaints about engine troubles, transmission problems, or excessive repair costs? 

Here’s a breakdown of the Toyota Highlander years to avoid:

1) 2003 Toyota Highlander

As the earliest model in the lineup, the 2003 Highlander experienced its fair share of teething issues. Common complaints from owners include:

• Engine Problems: Engine oil leaks and sludge build-up were frequent, which led to costly repairs. Many owners grew frustrated with repeated visits to the mechanic.
• Transmission Issues: Some vehicles struggled with smooth shifting, which caused a jerky driving experience and reduced the vehicle’s appeal.
• Electrical Gremlins: Power windows and locks often malfunctioned, inconveniencing families using the vehicle daily.

Despite being a constant expense on the pocket, the 2003 model set a precedent for Toyota to improve in subsequent years. It remains a year that buyers should approach with caution.

2) 2008 Toyota Highlander

The 2008 Highlander, despite its upgraded design and features, brought notable reliability concerns:

• Steering Issues: Owners reported problems with the power steering system, which could fail unexpectedly and lead to expensive repairs or even safety risks during driving.
• Excessive Oil Consumption: The engine consumed oil at alarming rates, which forced owners to monitor levels frequently and deal with increased maintenance costs.
• Dashboard Cracks: Aesthetic concerns arose as dashboards developed unsightly cracks prematurely, detracting from the overall interior quality.

These issues made the 2008 model a less desirable choice for used car buyers, especially those seeking a trouble-free ownership experience.

3) Concerns With the 2015 Toyota Highlander

While newer, the 2015 model faced criticism for the following:

• Transmission Problems: Hesitation and rough shifting were common, which made the driving experience less reliable and smooth.
• Interior Quality: Some components felt cheap and prone to wear, which disappointed buyers expecting Toyota’s usual standard of durability.
• Infotainment Glitches: Owners experienced unresponsive touchscreens and faulty software, which hampered the vehicle’s convenience and modern appeal.

Despite its modern features, the 2015 model disillusioned some buyers due to these recurring issues.

Also Read: Toyota 4Runner Years to Avoid

Why Toyota Highlander Issues Are Significant?

When purchasing a used SUV, repair costs and reliability are the most important factors. Models with recurring issues can drain your wallet and leave you stranded on the side of the road. Knowing the Toyota Highlander years to avoid will save you from unnecessary stress and expenses. 

Buying a used car often comes with some uncertainty, but taking proactive steps can reduce the risks. By focusing on common problems associated with certain years, you can better prepare yourself for pitfalls. 

For example, steering issues in older models, like those in the 2008 Highlander, could compromise driving safety if left unaddressed. Similarly, recurring engine problems in the 2003 model emphasize why proper maintenance is crucial for older vehicles. 

5 Tips for Identifying Reliable Toyota Highlanders

So, how can you avoid making this mistake? Here are a few tips to ensure you’re buying a reliable model:

Check Vehicle History Reports

Services like Carfax can reveal accident history, previous owners, and maintenance records. This step provides valuable information about car usage and helps avoid any vehicles with unresolved issues or underlying problems. 

Get a Pre-Purchase Inspection

Hire a trusted mechanic to examine the vehicle thoroughly. A professional inspection can identify problems that may not be apparent during a test drive. 

Focus on Maintenance Records

A well-maintained Highlander is less likely to have hidden issues. Consistent servicing and timely repairs are indicators of a vehicle’s reliability. 

Read Reviews and Forums

First-hand accounts from other Highlander owners can provide insights into a specific model’s strengths and weaknesses. Online forums and review platforms are great resources for gathering real-world feedback.

Look for Recalls and Repairs

Some vehicles have undergone recalls to address significant issues. Check whether the Highlander you’re considering has had necessary repairs completed under recalls.

Which Are the Reliable Toyota Highlander Years?

While this article focuses on the Toyota Highlander years to avoid, it’s worth noting that many Toyota Highlanders are dependable. Models from 2011 to 2014 and 2017 onwards were praised for their reliability, strong performance, and minimal complaints. 

These models boast improved engines, smoother transmissions, and higher-quality interiors, making them excellent choices for families and individuals. Reliable years models feature more refined safety features and technology advancements. For example, later models include modern infotainment systems, advanced driver-assistance features, and improved fuel efficiency—all of which are attractive for today’s buyers.

Additional Considerations When Buying Used SUVs

When shopping for a used Highlander, consider these additional tips:

Test Drive the Vehicle

During a test drive, pay attention to how the car handles, shifts, and brakes. Any unusual noises or vibrations should raise red flags.

Research Common Issues

Familiarize yourself with common problems reported for the year you’re considering. This knowledge can help you ask the right questions and negotiate better.

Check Recalls

Verify whether the model year has any outstanding recalls and ensure that necessary repairs have been completed.

Consider Extended Warranties

An extended warranty can provide peace of mind and protect you from unexpected repair costs. But don’t overlook the resale value of the vehicle. Reliable Toyota Highlander models tend to hold their value well, which can be beneficial if you plan to sell or trade in the car later. By factoring in long-term value, you ensure your investment pays off both in the short term and over the years.

Also Read: Toyota Sequoia 2023

Final Thoughts

Purchasing a used Toyota Highlander can be wise if you know which Toyota Highlander years to avoid. Models like 2003, 2008, and 2015 have raised red flags among owners due to common mechanical and aesthetic issues.

Take the time to do proper research and buy the right car. Whether checking reviews, seeking professional inspections, or comparing models, every step brings you closer to finding the right Highlander for your needs.

FAQs